The most important problems in any deal are rarely the legal ones. That was a core insight Jessica Catton Rinaldi, general counsel at Enwave Energy Corporation in Toronto, carried out of 12 years at Fasken – the personalities, timing, risk, and macro forces that determine a transaction's outcome long before the closing documents are executed. It has since become the foundation for how she runs her in-house legal team and for the advice she gives to any lawyer weighing a move to an in-house role.
From Fasken to district energy
Catton Rinaldi did not enter law expecting to close deals. She was drawn to oral advocacy – debate in undergrad, mooting in law school – and, after her first summer at Fasken, she was convinced litigation was where she was headed. Exposure to deal work changed that. "When I started working on more deal work, it really made sense to me and it felt like natural alignment," she says.
She stayed at Fasken for 12 years, rising from associate to partner in the corporate and securities group, working across public and private M&A, corporate finance and governance in sectors including energy, mining and technology. The lesson that stuck was less about technical mastery than about perspective. The most significant challenges in any deal – personalities, timing, macro risk – tend to sit upstream of the legal workstream, and knowing when to step back and distinguish between what is urgent and what is important has stayed with her since.
Building a legal function from scratch
In June 2021, Catton Rinaldi left private practice not because she was looking to leave, but because the opportunity was hard to refuse: to build Enwave's first in-house legal department, oversee human resources, and work in the green energy sector at a company that had operated without in-house legal counsel. "The idea of building something was really important to me," she says. The goal was to think carefully about "what processes, what tools, what people" to put in place so that legal could be genuinely embedded in the business rather than reactive to it.
She was deliberate about what she was not trying to replicate. "[O]ne of the things I wanted to make sure I wasn't doing was just building a law firm within the company," she says, "but that we were actually embedding ourselves as a value-added business partner in getting things done in the business." Her team now includes two lawyers and two law clerks, and one of her central goals has been building systems rather than dependencies on any one individual – processes and institutional knowledge that can scale. The framework she applies is straightforward: people, process, technology.
The legal complexity of district energy
Enwave has operated since the 1960s, starting as a not-for-profit serving downtown Toronto before growing into what it describes as Canada's leading low-carbon district energy owner-operator, providing heating and cooling to over 400 buildings in Toronto, Windsor, London, Markham and Charlottetown. About 20 years ago, the company built the Deep Lake Water Cooling (DLWC) System, which uses thermal energy drawn from the City of Toronto's potable water intake from Lake Ontario to cool hundreds of downtown buildings, eliminating the need for conventional on-site chillers.
Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan Board and IFM Investors officially took ownership of Enwave Energy Corporation on June 7, 2021, in a deal recognized in Lexpert's 2022 Awards of Excellence for Top Deals.
For the legal team, the work is anything but standardized. Each customer connection requires a bespoke, long-term agreement – not a simple template. Capital-intensive construction and infrastructure projects, procurement for critical plant operations, and municipal partnership arrangements governing shared underground pipe infrastructure all add to the scope. With roughly 20 percent of global carbon emissions coming from the built environment, according to Catton Rinaldi, Enwave builds and operates its infrastructure as a long-term proposition, independent of wherever carbon reduction sits in the political conversation at any given moment. The company's new waste-to-energy facility in Charlottetown, PEI – backed in part by the Canada Infrastructure Bank (CIB) – is set to process approximately 90 percent of the island's black cart waste and alleviate significant pressure on landfills.
Two roles, one portfolio
Catton Rinaldi's mandate covers both legal and HR – a pairing that she says works together better than it might first appear. Both functions share a foundation in governance, ethics and accountability, and both face the same cultural challenge: not everyone's first instinct is to call legal or HR, and shifting that perception is an ongoing part of the work. For external counsel, the team engages selectively – for complex projects that exceed in-house breadth, evolving areas of law requiring specialist depth, or when capacity is constrained. The requirement is that any firm they engage knows Enwave's business well enough to advise without context gaps; the company provides a critical service, and its plants need to run reliably day-to-day.
Advice for lawyers considering a move in-house
The clearest advice Catton Rinaldi offers any lawyer considering an in-house role is to get comfortable with ambiguity. In private practice, problems tend to arrive well-packaged; in-house, identifying the actual question is often the most work. Beyond that, in-house effectiveness depends on influence, not on technical output. "You could be an incredibly smart technical lawyer, but in order to be successful in-house, you need to be willing to understand the business, build partnerships," she says. Those who default to legal service delivery rather than genuine business partnership, in her observation, are the ones who struggle. That means learning the business deeply – the pain points, the revenue drivers, the desired outcome behind every request that lands on a lawyer's desk. Catton Rinaldi, who co-founded Young Women in Law while articling – a not-for-profit that continues to provide community and mentorship for women entering the legal profession – says the draw of an in-house role ultimately comes down to ownership: of decisions, of outcomes, and of an impact that is harder to claim from across a client table.


